Should Running Shoes Be a Size Bigger?

Should Running Shoes Be a Size Bigger
Running Shoes Running Shoes Advice

Making sure you have the most appropriate size whenever you buy footwear is important. This is not just so that they will feel comfortable when wearing them, but because there is a risk of injury, sometimes permanent injury, if you continuously wear footwear that is the wrong size.

In the case of running shoes, it is important that you are wearing the right size for similar reasons, however, there are some nuances when it comes to selecting which size of running shoe you should order. In this article we will explain what these are and how to make sure the size of running shoe you are wearing is the right size.

Why Running Shoes Can Feel Tight

If you have been wearing the same running shoes comfortably for some time, and they suddenly start to feel tight, there can be several reasons for this. Before we outline them, we are going to assume you not a growing child whose feet are getting bigger simply because of that growth.

For an adult, running shoes starting to feel tight can be for several reasons. The first is that your toenails have grown too long and need cutting. Another reason is that as we age, our feet can change shape and in particular they tend loose support and flatten.

Why Running Shoes Can Feel Tight

Pregnancy can cause a women’s feet to swell, and for everyone else, the list of reasons for feet swelling includes injuries, excess fluid, long periods of standing, or weight gain.

How to Measure Your Feet Properly

There are two main ways you could measure your feet. The first is in the store by the assistant, and this is likely to be done using something called the Brannock device. This iconic foot size measurer is something which everyone who has visited a shoe shop will have had their feet measured with.

The second way you can measure your foot size is basic but also very effective. You get a blank sheet of paper and wearing socks of a thickness that you are likely to wear when running, you draw around your foot using a pen. You then do the same with the other foot.

Using a ruler to measure the length of the longest part of the outline, and width at widest, whichever of the two foot sizes is the greater, is the one which you use to determine which running shoe size you need.

How Tight Your Running Shoes Should Be

When you put in a pair of running shoes, there is no single part of the foot that is going to identify whether they are too tight or not. Different parts of the foot react in different ways and it’s by tuning in to these parts you will be able to determine if the running shoes you are wearing fit correctly or are too tight.

How Tight Your Running Shoes Should Be


If your running shoes are too big, you are likely to get what just about everyone who has ever run or played sport has suffered from, and that is a blister. This is obviously caused by excessive rubbing from the back of the shoe on the heel area. You want the heel area to fit snuggly, but not that tight that it could constrict heel movement.


This is a critical part of the running shoe which provides the support and stability that are essential when you are running. Your running shoe should feel snug in this area, even before the laces are tied. This part of your foot may swell slightly when running so running shoes which are too tight will soon cause pain and discomfort.


As a result of the impact of each stride you take when running, naturally occurring fluids build up in your feet which is why there needs to be the wiggle room you often hear shoe store assistants asking about when you try shoes on. The rule of thumb, literally, is that you should have a thumb’s width of wiggle room between your big toe and the inside of your running shoe.

How to Select the Right Size of Running Shoe

Due to the natural widening and lengthening of your foot, due to the impact with the ground when you are running, the considered opinion is that you should select running shoes which are half a size longer than your normal shoe size. To determine the actual running shoe size, you should use a shoe size conversion chart.

One consideration is whether you tend to run fast over short distances or jog slowly over longer distances. If it is faster running you do, then you want your running shoes to be as snug as possible as this helps with pace.

Bestseller No. 1
Under Armour mens Charged Assert 8 Running Shoe, Black/Black, 11 US
  • NEUTRAL: For runners who need a balance of flexibility & cushioning
  • Lightweight mesh upper with 3-color digital print delivers complete breathability
  • Durable leather overlays for stability & that locks in your midfoot
  • EVA sockliner provides soft, step-in comfort
  • Charged Cushioning midsole uses compression molded foam for even greater responsiveness & durability, providing optimal cushioning & energy return
SaleBestseller No. 2
adidas Women's Cloud foam Pure Running Shoe, White/White/Black, 7 Medium US
  • Stretchy, mesh running shoes with extra cushioning for all-day comfort
  • Stretchable mesh upper for breathability
  • Combined Cloudfoam midsole and outsole for step-in comfort and superior cushioning
  • Cloudfoam memory sockliner molds to the foot for superior step-in comfort
SaleBestseller No. 3
Saucony Women's Versafoam Excursion TR13 Trail Running Shoe, Black, 8.5
  • Versafoam cushioning for more comfort than ever before
  • A cushy stack of VERSAFOAM cushioning feels responsive to provide every level of runner comfortable strides
  • The triangular-lugged outsole grips the terrain for rock-solid footing
  • The trail-specific mesh with supportive overlays locks your foot into place and protects from trail debris
SaleBestseller No. 4
ASICS Men's Gel-Venture 7 Running Shoes, 10.5M, Electric Blue/Sheet Rock
  • Ortholite X-40 Sockliner - This premium sockliner features higher rebound properties while providing excellent moisture management and a high-level of breathability (Ortholite is a registered trademark of ATP Manufacturing LLC.)
SaleBestseller No. 5
Nike Mens Free RN 2018 942836 002 - Size 9 Black/Anthracite
  • fabric-and-synthetic
  • Rubber sole
  • Circular knit upper with spandex for a hugging fit.
  • Dynamic Fit technology integrates Flywire cables through the laces for an adaptive, supportive fit
  • Lightly padded tongue and stretchy collar for a supportive wear

Last update on 2021-05-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API